Had a 3/4ton ‘10 Z71. Before that I had an’06 Dodge 4wd w/ LS. No comparison. Required much more throttle to get the Dodge to engage both rear wheels resulting in rooster tails/slippage of rear end etc. The GM would slip one wheel and immediately engage regardless of throttle. I much preferred the Eaton and despite more clearance , better Off-road tires and a more “truck like” appearance the Dodge would not do better.... I can’t speak to the toughness of either unit bc neither failed to do what they were supposed to. I drove plenty of slick clay roads in both but I know enough to know a 3/4+ ton rig isn’t for bogging....